Judges challenge government restrictions on public expression, raising important questions about First Amendment protections and judicial independence.
By Fauzia J. Choudhury
A new legal battle over freedom of expression among U.S. immigration judges has reached the nation’s highest court, as the National Association of Immigration Judges (NAIJ) seeks to challenge government restrictions on judges’ ability to speak publicly about immigration-related matters.
On November 17, 2026, the association filed a new petition with the U.S. Supreme Court, seeking the opportunity to challenge restrictions imposed by the Department of Justice’s Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) directly in federal court.
At the center of the dispute is the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which protects freedom of speech and expression. The judges’ association argues that existing government policies restrict immigration judges from publicly discussing immigration policies and their employing agency, even when speaking in their personal capacities.
The case is being represented by the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University. The organization maintains that immigration law and policy are matters of significant public interest and that judges should have the opportunity to share their professional experiences and observations with the public.
The legal dispute dates back to 2020, when the judges’ association first challenged the government’s restrictions on public statements. The challenged policies include requirements for prior approval before judges can make certain public statements related to their official responsibilities.
The case has since moved through several stages of the federal court system. On May 26, 2026, the Supreme Court vacated an earlier decision by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals on procedural grounds. However, the high court did not resolve the underlying constitutional question of whether the government’s restrictions violate the First Amendment.
In August 2026, the Fourth Circuit dismissed the case on jurisdictional grounds. The court issued a revised decision on November 4, setting the stage for the association’s latest petition to the Supreme Court.
NAIJ argues that government employees must have access to an effective judicial process to protect their constitutional rights. The association contends that forcing judges through prolonged administrative procedures could make it difficult to obtain meaningful and timely judicial review of alleged violations of their First Amendment rights.
The association has also raised concerns that restricting immigration judges from speaking publicly could limit important perspectives on immigration law, government policies and the administration of justice.
However, the Supreme Court has not yet ruled on whether the challenged government policies violate the First Amendment. The latest petition primarily raises the question of whether immigration judges can seek direct relief in federal court rather than being required to pursue administrative remedies first.
The case has broader implications for the constitutional rights of federal employees, freedom of expression and public access to informed perspectives on government policies. Its outcome could have significance beyond the immigration court system, depending on how the courts address the legal questions involved.
