Progressive base split over Israel stance and political loyalty in NYC mayoral race
New York | Shah J. Choudhury
A new equation is emerging in New York City’s mayoral race. Progressive voters who once rallied behind City Comptroller Brad Lander are now deeply divided: will they follow his endorsement of Zohran Mamdani, or shift their support toward Andrew Cuomo?
Lander, who drew strong backing from progressive Jewish voters during the Democratic primary, publicly endorsed Mamdani after the first round. But many within his base remain hesitant — primarily due to Mamdani’s outspoken stance on Israel and Palestine, which some voters see as too critical of Israel.
According to post-primary data, only 56% of Lander’s voters ranked Mamdani as their next choice, while others abstained or opted for Cuomo instead. The numbers suggest a growing fracture within New York’s progressive coalition.
One Jewish voter told The Times of Israel:
“I like Mamdani’s integrity and progressive agenda, but I’m uncomfortable with his comments on Israel.”
Another said,
“We trust Brad Lander’s leadership, but Mamdani feels like a different kind of gamble.”
Even Lander himself acknowledged the unease.
“I’m continuing conversations with voters,” he said. “It’s important they understand why I believe Mamdani is the right choice for New York.”
Political analysts note that this rift reflects a larger shift within American progressive politics — where questions of foreign policy, identity, and moral conviction are increasingly shaping local races.
As New York’s mayoral contest tightens, the divide within Lander’s base could prove decisive in determining whether Mamdani’s left-wing appeal can overcome Cuomo’s centrist resurgence.
Source: The Times of Israel —
