By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
The GenerationThe GenerationThe Generation
  • USA
    USA
    Show More
    Top News
    UN Chief Urges Continued US Foreign Aid Amid Trump’s Pause Announcement
    February 2, 2025
    A 4-Year-Old’s Mom ate his Ice Cream. He Called the Cops
    March 14, 2025
    US Judge Blocks Deportation of Venezuelans in Colorado Under Wartime Law
    April 19, 2025
    Latest News
    Forensic expert says Jeffrey Epstein’s prison death was a homicide: report
    November 17, 2026
    Trump says US taking seriously report of possible Iranian dirty bomb plot in Washington
    November 17, 2026
    Jensen Huang says he would be ‘honored’ to return as Nvidia CEO if board asks
    November 17, 2026
    Trump says US taking possible Iranian plot targeting Washington ‘very seriously’
    November 17, 2026
  • New York
    New York
    Show More
    Top News
    Rent Guidelines Board meeting in Brooklyn gets rowdy with shouting over proposed increases
    June 12, 2026
    Heat wave forecast: Dangerous temps to continue into July 4 holiday
    July 2, 2026
    New York Balances The Books By Building Debt, Watchdogs Warn
    July 28, 2026
    Latest News
    Subway passenger bites off-duty MTA worker’s ear during fight
    November 17, 2026
    New York senior perseveres as she passes 40 years living with multiple sclerosis
    November 17, 2026
    Brooklyn stabbing suspect’s employment history with NYC schools raises questions
    November 17, 2026
    Piscataway, N.J. residents say traffic apps are disrupting their quiet neighborhood
    November 17, 2026
  • Politics
    Politics
    Show More
    Top News
    Joe Biden Plans To Ban Logging In US Old-growth Forests In 2025
    December 26, 2023
    Donald Trump Ranked As Worst US President In History, With Joe Biden 14th
    February 29, 2024
    Lawmakers Say They Should Analyze Protests Response
    May 31, 2024
    Latest News
    Illegal alien accused of attempted murder at large after Rikers release despite ICE detainer: DHS
    November 17, 2026
    Maggie Haberman claims disturbing turning point in Donald Trump’s relationship with Susie Wiles
    November 17, 2026
    Trump meets key US regional allies in Manila ahead of China visit
    November 17, 2026
    Protesters temporarily shut down ex-Border Patrol Commander Greg Bovino’s event at Rutgers University
    November 17, 2026
  • World
    World
    Show More
    Top News
    Arab League slams Israel siege of Gaza, demands aid for Gazans
    October 12, 2023
    Bangladesh hands over humanitarian aid to Palestine
    October 31, 2023
    Hezbollah’s anti-ship missiles bolster its threat to US navy
    November 9, 2023
    Latest News
    NATO must be ready for conflict at any moment, communications agency chief says
    November 17, 2026
    COP31 SUMMIT: Draft deal calls for faster ‘action’ to exit fossil fuels
    November 17, 2026
    Palestinian woman killed, 10 wounded in settler gunfire, official TV says
    November 17, 2026
    Top UN court ruling on Myanmar genocide to be watched for clues on Gaza
    November 17, 2026
  • Finance & Business
    Finance & Business
    Show More
    Top News
    How Banks And The Fed Are Preparing For A US Default – And Chaos To Follow
    September 3, 2023
    Corporate Greed is not to Blame for High Inflation, SF Fed Says
    June 16, 2024
    Eligible Taxpayers Could Receive Up to $4,427 in Tax Credits
    October 13, 2026
    Latest News
    Eligible Taxpayers Could Receive Up to $4,427 in Tax Credits
    October 13, 2026
    Corporate Greed is not to Blame for High Inflation, SF Fed Says
    June 16, 2024
    How Banks And The Fed Are Preparing For A US Default – And Chaos To Follow
    September 3, 2023
  • EpaperNew
Search
  • About Us
  • Our Awards
  • My Bookmarks
  • Opinion
  • Crime
  • Science & Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Economy
  • Fashion
  • Election
  • Feature
  • Charity
  • Literature
  • Security
  • US & Canada
  • Nature
  • Cooking
Copyright @2023 – All Right Reserved by The Generation.
Reading: Left, Right, Harris, Trump: All Prisoners of Political Nostalgia In An Era Few Understand
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
The GenerationThe Generation
  • USA
  • New York
  • Politics
  • World
  • EpaperNew
Search
  • Crime
  • Economy
  • Election
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • US & Canada
  • Finance & Business
  • Charity
  • Cooking
  • Fashion
  • Feature
  • Literature
  • Nature
  • Science & Technology
  • Security
  • Sports
Follow US
  • About Us
  • My Bookmarks
Copyright @2023 – All Right Reserved by The Generation.
Opinion

Left, Right, Harris, Trump: All Prisoners of Political Nostalgia In An Era Few Understand

Published: November 8, 2024
Share
9 Min Read
SHARE

Tuesday, November 5, 2024
Year : 2, Issue: 10

by Rafael Behr

Donald Trump’s record of refusal to concede defeat after the last US election should have disqualified him from running in this one. His criminal indictments should have meant banishment from mainstream politics. His campaign rhetoric – a rambling litany of bigotry and spite – should not have carried beyond the paranoid fringe.
But what use are should and shouldn’t against the brute force of can and does? Things that are supposed to be self-evident in a constitutional democracy have ceased to be obvious to millions of Americans. We don’t need to wait for all votes to be counted to wish for a stronger cultural inoculation against tyranny.
A healthier body politic would not have been infected by Trump’s candidacy. How did the democratic immune system fail? He is gifted with a malign kind of charisma, but it needed a confluence of economic stagnation, cultural polarisation and technological revolution over many years to achieve maximum contagion.
There is always a risk of romanticising the past when coping with anxiety in the present. Aggressive nationalism that bristles with racism, misogyny and swaggering machismo is an old style in American politics. There is also nothing especially new in polarised social attitudes. Culture wars have been waged with varying degrees of intensity for generations.
What stands out as a uniquely 21st-century innovation is the segregation of political tribes into discrete and self-reinforcing information silos. Formerly, even in times of fierce political division, there were institutions and rules that governed debate. There were commonly agreed facts that might be subject to rival interpretation while still connecting partisans of opposite views to a shared reality.
That way of conducting politics is not obsolete, but it is rooted in analogue systems. It relies on real-life interactions, deliberations, clunky old institutions, meandering conversations, small talk. It is the stuff of people mingling in assemblies and town halls, breaking bread together. It is the opposite of politics played in digital mode where the platforms on which debate is conducted are also engines of radicalisation; where differences of opinion are accelerated into irreconcilable enmities.
This isn’t an elegy for some pre-internet golden age of enlightened public discourse. Prejudice, misinformation, sheer stupidity and abuse of power were abundant enough when information flows were tightly controlled and volumes were a tiny fraction of what they are now.
An apparent correlation between extreme politics and the rise of social media doesn’t prove a causal link. But there is a plausible argument that a very online culture, marked by short attention spans, narcissism and impatient consumer appetites, has a more natural affinity with shallow demagoguery than with representative democracy.
The whole apparatus of voting for a candidate who might not satisfy your exact needs, and probably doesn’t embody all the values you hold sacred, but might at least make some half-decent decisions for the country as a whole over the coming years, feels oddly antiquated. It is alien to the click-and-collect spirit of digital commerce.
A democratic election is the antithesis of an internet transaction. It contains not just an expectation of delayed gratification, but a guarantee of frustration. Compromise, imperfection and disappointment are the necessary price for having a government that tries to balance the complex demands of a variegated society.
The alternative is a political movement, such as the Maga cult, that treats elections as a cry of rage or exultant self-actualisation. Trump’s campaign has never construed voting in terms of civic choice, with more than one potentially legitimate outcome. It was always going to be either a heroic restoration of the rightful president or another iteration of the deep-state conspiracy against him. There is no place for defeat in the script except as material to bolster the claim of a higher victory.
It is a mode of campaigning that is hostile to the basic premise of a democratic ballot, which is that either side might win and counting votes actually counts.
It also exploits a culture of political journalism that measures professional integrity by a refusal to pick sides. It has been peculiar to observe liberal American media continuing to apply their conventional reporting templates, which contain the implicit judgment that the two candidates have equivalent democratic credentials. That is absurd when one of them transparently despises democracy.
Much of America’s moderate conservative and liberal establishment seems to have spent the campaign going through the motions of political normalcy, hoping to stir the system into resilience by operation of muscle memory. It doesn’t work.
But ringing the alarm at the spectre of fascism doesn’t work either. There is no doubt that Trump’s temperament and ambitions are fascistic. He admires dictators, lusts after absolute power, speaks of political critics as enemies and boasts of his willingness to crush them with armed organs of the state.
And yet calling that kind of politics by its proper name doesn’t provoke any scruple among his supporters. Partly that is because the currency of comparison with 20th-century dictators has been dulled by overuse. “Fascist” is a label that has been applied too casually and too often as unthinking abuse to be rehabilitated as a tool with moral precision and rhetorical impact more than 100 years after it was coined.
That doesn’t mean the lessons of the 1920s and 1930s are irrelevant to the current predicament. It is easy to find disturbing parallels, and the connection can’t be ignored when white supremacists and card-carrying neo-Nazis are an active cadre in the new radical-right coalition.
But there is also a danger for liberal opinion in leaning too heavily on the familiar cautionary tales from history.
Casting the threat as a resurgence of something old – a zombie ideology risen from its postwar grave – preserves the convenient idea of liberal democracy as the more modern and more highly evolved political system. It is the instinct to dismiss nationalism as an ideological retirement home for angry white people whose skills don’t equip them to compete in a dynamic, globalised economy, and who express their frustration as bigoted reaction against progressive social change.
There might be a dose of truth in that analysis – but it doesn’t contain an argument in favour of liberal democracy, beyond the implication that only stupid, bad people oppose it. Unsurprisingly, those same people don’t find that argument very persuasive.
The awkward truth for those of us who rally in defence of liberal democracy today is that it has undergone no obvious renewal since its peak at the end of the last century. We, no less than the nationalists, are imprisoned by nostalgia, wishing the future could be more like the past. And so we find ourselves constantly testing the limits of analogue protection against a virus that is digitally borne.
Author is a Guardian columnist

Donald Trump is weaker than he looks
The Triad of Success: Building a Flexible, Scalable, and Efficient Foundation for Generative AI
New Video Shows Hectic Aftermath of Shelter Scuffle Involving NYC Mayor Adams Adviser Tim Pearson
With US Leadership and European Support we Ukrainians May at Last Have Peace. But Don’t Let Russia Off the Hook
Whenever You Point Fingers, Remember That Three Fingers Point Back At You

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Share This Article
Facebook Whatsapp Whatsapp Copy Link Print
Previous Article Why I’m Voting for Donald Trump
Next Article Bangali Ghosts Vie for the Fishes

Stay Connected

1.2KFollowersLike
13KFollowersFollow
1.2KFollowersFollow
1.4KSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

Illegal alien accused of attempted murder at large after Rikers release despite ICE detainer: DHS
Politics
November 17, 2026
Maggie Haberman claims disturbing turning point in Donald Trump’s relationship with Susie Wiles
Politics
November 17, 2026
Trump meets key US regional allies in Manila ahead of China visit
Politics
November 17, 2026
NATO must be ready for conflict at any moment, communications agency chief says
World
November 17, 2026
COP31 SUMMIT: Draft deal calls for faster ‘action’ to exit fossil fuels
World
November 17, 2026

Quick links

  • About Us
  • Our Awards
  • My Bookmarks

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Editor
Sadia J. Choudhury
Executive Editor
Shah J. Choudhury, Mubin Khan & Salman J. Choudhury
Member of Editor’s Board
Husneara Choudhury, Fauzia J. Choudhury, Santa Islam & DevRaj A. Nath.

A Ruposhi Bangla Entertainment Network

By

Office Address
New York Office:
70-52 Broadway 1A, Jackson Heights, NY-11372, United States.
Contact
Tel: +1 (718) 496-5000
Email: info@thegenerationus.com
newsthegeneration@gmail.com
The GenerationThe Generation
Follow US
Copyright @2023 – All Right Reserved by The Generation.