By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
The GenerationThe GenerationThe Generation
  • USA
    USA
    Show More
    Top News
    Dad charged with murder after 10-year-old son dies in rollover crash, TX officials say
    September 4, 2023
    Claudia Goldin wins 2023 Nobel economics prize
    October 11, 2023
    Marijuana Smoke May be Harmful to Health, Can Affect Your Heart
    November 2, 2023
    Latest News
    The Fourth of July: The Meaning and Promise of Freedom
    July 4, 2025
    House Passes Trump’s ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ After All-Night Debate
    July 3, 2025
    Trump Targets Musk and Zohran: How Real Is the Threat to Their U.S. Citizenship?
    July 3, 2025
    Trump’s Budget Bill Moves Closer to Becoming Law — Key Sticking Points Remain
    July 2, 2025
  • New York
    New York
    Show More
    Top News
    Bangladeshi Actor achieve international in US
    October 26, 2023
    NY District Cancels Classes After Multiple Fights Break out at Same Time at High School
    November 24, 2023
    Winter Weather Arrives As NYC Migrant Crisis Worsens
    December 20, 2023
    Latest News
    Mamdani Emerges as NYC Mayoral Front-Runner — Poll Shows Socialist Beating Cuomo, Adams, and Sliwa
    July 4, 2025
    Kathy Hochul’s Re-election Prospects Clouded by Voter Uncertainty and Republican Challenges
    July 2, 2025
    Mamdani Responds to Trump’s Deportation Threat: “We Won’t Accept This Intimidation”
    July 2, 2025
    NYC Primary Election: Zohran Mamdani Defeats Andrew Cuomo in 3rd Round of Ranked Choice Voting
    July 2, 2025
  • Politics
    Politics
    Show More
    Top News
    Joe Biden Plans To Ban Logging In US Old-growth Forests In 2025
    December 26, 2023
    Donald Trump Ranked As Worst US President In History, With Joe Biden 14th
    February 29, 2024
    Lawmakers Say They Should Analyze Protests Response
    May 31, 2024
    Latest News
    Trump Judge Nominee told DOJ Lawyers to Ignore Court Orders on Deportations: Whistleblower
    July 5, 2025
    Trump to Congress: ‘NO ONE GOES ON VACATION’ until spending bill passes
    July 5, 2025
    US Lawmaker Links JFK Assassination to His Opposition to Nuclear Israel, Questions Own, Trump’s Safety
    July 5, 2025
    With Bernie Sanders’ Backing, Zohran Mamdani Gains Momentum in NYC Mayoral Race”
    June 18, 2025
  • World
    World
    Show More
    Top News
    Arab League slams Israel siege of Gaza, demands aid for Gazans
    October 12, 2023
    Bangladesh hands over humanitarian aid to Palestine
    October 31, 2023
    Hezbollah’s anti-ship missiles bolster its threat to US navy
    November 9, 2023
    Latest News
    Murder or Mystery? Monir Mia Found Dead, Police Silent
    July 3, 2025
    UN Chief Condemns Israel’s ‘Unacceptable’ Killing of Aid Seekers in Gaza
    June 25, 2025
    Iran–Israel Ceasefire in Effect Amid Tensions, Accusations, and Uncertainty
    June 24, 2025
    Iran–Israel Ceasefire in Effect Amid Tensions, Accusations, and Uncertainty
    July 4, 2025
  • Finance & Business
    Finance & Business
    Show More
    Top News
    How Banks And The Fed Are Preparing For A US Default – And Chaos To Follow
    September 3, 2023
    Corporate Greed is not to Blame for High Inflation, SF Fed Says
    June 16, 2024
    Latest News
    Corporate Greed is not to Blame for High Inflation, SF Fed Says
    June 16, 2024
    How Banks And The Fed Are Preparing For A US Default – And Chaos To Follow
    September 3, 2023
  • EpaperNew
Search
  • About Us
  • Our Awards
  • My Bookmarks
  • Opinion
  • Crime
  • Science & Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Economy
  • Fashion
  • Election
  • Feature
  • Charity
  • Literature
  • Security
  • US & Canada
  • Nature
  • Cooking
Copyright @2023 – All Right Reserved by The Generation.
Reading: The Funny Thing About Emotional Truths: Revisiting The Hasan Minhaj Scandal
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
The GenerationThe Generation
  • USA
  • New York
  • Politics
  • World
  • EpaperNew
Search
  • Crime
  • Economy
  • Election
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • US & Canada
  • Finance & Business
  • Charity
  • Cooking
  • Fashion
  • Feature
  • Literature
  • Nature
  • Science & Technology
  • Security
  • Sports
Follow US
  • About Us
  • My Bookmarks
Copyright @2023 – All Right Reserved by The Generation.
Opinion

The Funny Thing About Emotional Truths: Revisiting The Hasan Minhaj Scandal

Published January 21, 2024
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

Tuesday, January 9, 2024
Year : 1, Issue : 19


by Syeda Ahmed

Depending on the framework it wasn’t really a scandal at all. An up-and-coming comedian embellishing his stories: raising the stakes to win a few more laughs is hardly groundbreaking news. Yet when that comedian is Hasan Minhaj, who’s known to blur the lines between his comedy and political messaging, the public seems to take the difference between fact and fiction very seriously.
From his early days as a correspondent on The Daily Show to the host of his own Netflix Specials like Homecoming King Minhaj used his comedy to shine light on personal experiences of racism and Islamophobia he’d experienced growing up as an Indian-American Muslim post 9/11. His wild success and witty political commentary made him a favorite for the new host of The Daily Show following Trevor Noah’s retirement until a New Yorker article fact-checked the integrity of those stories ruined his chances. As it turns out, America has a soft spot for skinny guys with funny names until they’re accused of lying, even when it’s inherent to the nature of their job.

The 10 minute long article by Claire Malone deep dived into the discrepancies between the narratives of racism that underlie the humor of Minhaj’s shows and what “actually’ happened. After sitting down with Minhaj and getting him to admit on record to embellishing some of his stories to reveal the greater “emotional truths,” Malone wrote an expose style article about how his made up racism actually undermines the very real experiences of Islamophobia people go through. In a 20 minute youtube video responding to the accusations leveled against him, Minhaj accuses the New Yorker of leaving out essential context in their discussions and stands by his “emotional truths,” not in defense of lying but because his sets were meant to speak to universal experiences that Muslims and South Asians go through.

Despite the explanation video, including audio and email receipts that made it very clear that The New Yorker cherry picked, and at times completely misrepresented the snippets that made it into the article, a lot of folks had already made up their mind about him. Most people know better than to expect the complete and utter truth from comedians, but Malone’s article suggested that Minhaj was emotionally manipulative for creating sets with social justice undertones when they weren’t the complete truth.

The fallacy of this framework is that Minhaj presented real evidence that these were based on true stories. Maybe they were both in the wrong for their lack of transparency and selective narratives, but the truth is emotional truths are a lot less problematic than Claire Malone would like us to think. As a prolific reader of realistic fiction, a genre that often uses universal experiences of social struggle as a backdrop for a gut-wrenching story, I can tell you that emotional truths are a literary device. And as the daughter of storytellers who double as Desi parents with a flair for the dramatic, I can tell you that emotional truths allow us to better understand and resonate with the stories that would otherwise go untold.

Comics get to say all the things that might otherwise be too provocative for polite society. Taking part in a stand up comedy show means entering into a social agreement that permits the comedian to take creative liberties with parts of their stories in exchange for a few chuckles and eye-opening perspectives. Comedians like Hasan Minhaj using their storytelling skills to advance diverse and necessary perspectives should not have to go on trial.

Even if Minhaj was deserving of some of the heat he received, the shoddy framework of Malone’s New Yorker article was at best petty, and at worst counterproductive. She argued that Minhaj’s comedy downplays the urgency of real racism, when in reality her smear campaign against Minhaj probably delegitimizes South Asian and Muslim voices more than he ever did.
Although Minhaj has recovered from the setback, with the New York Times even going as far as to suggest that this scandal was the best thing to happen to his career after the success of his most recent special “Off with His Head,” it seems that he’s permanently out of the running for host of the Daily Show. The scandal that wasn’t really a scandal has still done its damage because we’ve missed the opportunity to see an Indian American Muslim final in the driver’s seat of such an influential industry. The real punchline of this joke is another Muslim American being a casualty of America’s so-called “investigative journalism”.

Author is a student at the Bronx High School of Science.

You Might Also Like

Bangladeshi by Name, but Betraying the Nation — A Shameful Reality

No Bail for Rape Accused: A Legal Reform We Urgently Need

Congress Has To Wake Up And Stop Trump’s War Path With Iran

When will Mob Violence End in Bangladesh?

Chanchal Mahmud — The Eye That Captured Light and Life

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp Copy Link Print
By Syeda Ahmed
Previous Article IMF Chief Says Ai Holds Risks, ‘Tremendous Opportunity’ For Global Economy
Next Article With The Fake Drama Of The Iowa Caucuses Over, We Can Focus On Trump’s Real Dangers

Stay Connected

1.2kFollowersLike
13kFollowersFollow
1.2kFollowersFollow
1.4kSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

Mamdani Emerges as NYC Mayoral Front-Runner — Poll Shows Socialist Beating Cuomo, Adams, and Sliwa
New York July 4, 2025
The Fourth of July: The Meaning and Promise of Freedom
USA July 4, 2025
House Passes Trump’s ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ After All-Night Debate
USA July 3, 2025
Murder or Mystery? Monir Mia Found Dead, Police Silent
World July 3, 2025
Trump Targets Musk and Zohran: How Real Is the Threat to Their U.S. Citizenship?
USA July 3, 2025

Quick links

  • About Us
  • Our Awards
  • My Bookmarks

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Editor
Sadia J. Choudhury
Executive Editor
Shah J. Choudhury, Mubin Khan & Salman J. Choudhury
Member of Editor’s Board
Husneara Choudhury, Fauzia J. Choudhury, Santa Islam & DevRaj A. Nath.

A Ruposhi Bangla Entertainment Network

By

Office Address
New York Office:
70-52 Broadway 1A, Jackson Heights, NY-11372, United States.
Contact
Tel: +1 (718) 496-5000
Email: info@thegenerationus.com
newsthegeneration@gmail.com
The GenerationThe Generation
Follow US
Copyright @2023 – All Right Reserved by The Generation.