Maurice Brown
The Trump administration recently announced that it’s invoking the Defense Protection Act to put $42 million of the public’s money toward building the dangerous Constitution Pipeline. This is a law that’s intended only to be invoked during emergency wartime, but Trump is shamelessly using it as a political ploy to push a pipeline that New York doesn’t need — and it would likely only go toward fueling more of the massive polluting AI data centers that nobody wants.
This is just a continuation of Trump’s crusade to force this pipeline and more fossil fuels on New Yorkers. When he spoke in Syracuse last month, he claimed that New Yorkers “got no money” because of our fracking ban, and that decisionmakers are “killing the East Coast,” by not allowing the Constitution Pipeline. This was obviously nonsense. A decade ago, New Yorkers made the good decision to ban fracking and deny the Constitution Pipeline in order to protect our local businesses, farms, water and public health. Despite what he wants us to think, Trump’s tirade isn’t actually about making New Yorkers’ lives better. The truth is, fracking and a new mega-pipeline would only harm New Yorkers.
There is no stated need for the Constitution Pipeline, but Trump and the Williams Company are trying to circumvent New York’s authority to protect our water and build the pipeline anyway.
Typically, when a company seeks to build a pipeline, there’s an energy utility attached to buy the gas it will bring. But no utility has agreed to purchase gas from the Constitution pipeline. Plus, the pipeline network that it would connect into is already at capacity, meaning there’s nowhere for this gas to go. It’s clear that there would be no public benefit to New Yorkers. So who is it for? We can look to Ohio for answers, where the Williams Company recently built a new pipeline that sends gas directly to power a new AI data center. It’s a safe assumption that’s what Williams wants to do here, too.
According to experts, AI data centers that run “behind-the-meter,” meaning they operate independently from the energy grid using their own fracked gas source, are raising our energy bills. And with the rapid expansion of these data centers across the country, that’s driving new demand for fracked gas, also at a cost to everyday people. New Yorkers didn’t ban fracking more than a decade ago just to undo it years later for the big tech industry’s benefit. Our waterways, farms and health aren’t for sale to the highest AI bidder.
We need to keep moving away from fracked gas and other fossil fuels, and we can. In the decade since New York banned fracking and first denied the Constitution Pipeline, renewable energy technology has only improved. Countries across the globe are proving there’s no need to expand fracked gas or any fossil fuels, because renewables are more reliable, cheaper and perform better.
Luckily, Trump’s funding push doesn’t mean the Constitution Pipeline is a done deal — far from it. And so far, Gov. Kathy Hochul has held strong to protect our fracking ban and New York’s authority to deny the pipeline. She’s also the only governor in the country to put a moratorium on new AI data centers. But even with the moratorium, the industry is attempting to build new data centers in the Finger Lakes, Genesee County, the Hudson Valley and more. As Trump and his friends in the fossil fuel and big tech industries work together to rapidly expand with no regard for our health, safety or wallets, Hochul must stand strong to uphold these decisions and protect New Yorkers from fracking, the Constitution Pipeline and AI data centers. No matter how much Trump and his cronies try to bully New York.
